Jump to content

Hip Scoring In Breeding Stock


whiskedaway
 Share

Recommended Posts

If a bitch has had a litter of puppies, and the breeder is still waiting on hip scores for her and won't get them for six weeks, would you go with the litter or not?

I personally feel it should have been done earlier, but I just wanted to get some opinions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Call me a cynic, but 6 weeks! :grimace:

I've never had H & E results take that long to come back, 2 weeks tops, even with the AVA. And just when did she have the xrays taken? It could not have been when she was pregnant surely???? :eek:

Sounds like a story to me - as Snagglepuss would say - "exit, stage left". :bolt:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah I didn't think they took that long, but I haven't had my girl's done yet so I wasn't sure.

And good point about having them done when she was pregnant!

There's a few other things that don't add up as well that made me scratch my head, but they're regarding health tests we don't do in my breed so I wasn't sure.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sounds dodgy to me too. Scores are usually back in about two weeks or less. They couldn't have done the x-rays when the bitch was pregnant and would have rocks in their head to do them after she whelped when all the joints are loose, so the x-rays would have been done months ago.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They could be waiting for the litter to be weaned and then do the hips after the milk has dried up. Given the positioning when doing hip xrays and the fact most vets will knock the dog out, i wouldn't like to have it done while the bitch was pregnant.

It may be reasons too, as to why they haven't done it - was it an opps mateing? Or did the bitch come in unexpectedly? There are alls sorts of possibilities out there - I wouldn't want to jump to any conclusions until I knew more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't do it!! I have been stung in exactly this situation - bought a large breed bitch puppy from an interstate breeder, had been advised of the father's hip score (which was a bit higher than the average (18) for the breed) and the breeder told me she was waiting for the mothers results to come back... I, somewhat stupidly, believed her when she told me the x-rays looked fabulous and that all would be well, expecting a really low score.

After several MONTHS of nagging with no reply, I finally got her to answer the question and it turned out the mother's hips were scored at 40!! Of course, it was all the scorer's fault :rolleyes: I was completely devastated, but all I could do was wait to get my girl x-rayed & scored when she was old enough. She came back with an amazing hip score all things considered (total of 9, waaay below the breed average) but unfortunately her elbows were 3:3 :(

I desexed her and she is now living the life of Riley as a spoilt pet, but it was extremely traumatic at the time. Yes it was my fault for going ahead, but you live and learn...

It really isn't worth the risk & the heartache - I would never take someone at their word again... make the decision when you can see the scores in black & white. Of course it's no guarantee that something won't go wrong but it's the best we can do. Good luck! :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks guys. Have passed on all your thoughts, cousin has decided not to go with this breeder and said she had a bad feeling about it so wanted some opinions. She got a reply from another breeder this morning and all of those health tests check out and will be going with them instead. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The xrays themselves would be potentially damaging to the foetuses, not to mention the GA/sedation risk to the pups, so surely she wouldn't have had them done during pregnancy.

Maybe they had the Pennhip done? I know you have to send them away to the US to be read, not sure how long the results take to come back. I assume with digital xrays these days though, it wouldn't be too long.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Six weeks hey, sounds dodgy to me. In a breed where hip scoring is the norm, I wouldn't breed a bitch who hadn't had hers done. What happens if the scores come back and they're crap... there's no point shutting the stable door once the horse has bolted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Penn Hip can be read here in Australia, Dr Grahame Allen is licensed to read and score here in Australia, I believe there are a number of other vets that are licensed now to read and score here in Australia.

I just find that the cost of Penn Hip being so much more expensive to do X-raying, as well as after doing research on Penn Hip, I prefer to stay with X-raying.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Three of my 16 month old labradors were Penn hipped (and four xrayed for AVA)on Thursday 27th October 2011. Date received in US 27th October, 2011. Time differences apply I should imagine.

Report date: 9th November 2011. I received results today.

Regarding the original question: If the breed required other DNA tests, and if they had not been performed either I would run.......in a very fast manner. In fact, I would have started to run...already.

Good luck. Try to check extended pedigree as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Penn Hip can be read here in Australia, Dr Grahame Allen is licensed to read and score here in Australia, I believe there are a number of other vets that are licensed now to read and score here in Australia.

That's not correct - PennHIP scoring can only be done in the US. There are many vets in Australia that have chosen to pay for the training and the licence to do PennHIP xrays, but nobody outside the US is authorised to score through the PennHIP scheme.

Sylvia

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I rang the AVA I was advised that there were several vets here now licensed to read Penn Hips.

Obviously the answer I got from them last year was incorrect. I apologise for misleading everyone.

No probs - you were only passing on what you were told by someone who should know - it's a worry that they don't :eek:

Cheers,

Sylvia

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are you sure it is read & score in Australia?? Its more likely to be able to offer PennHip rays. A vet needs specialised training & certification, as well as the eqiupment just to be able to take the rays for evaluation.

The rays need to be sent to PennHIP Analysis Center for evaluation.

Check out the website http://research.vet.upenn.edu/pennhip/GeneralInformation/WhatisPennHIP/tabid/3232/Default.aspx

Edited by Poodle Mum
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...