Thanks for your replies. It's reassuring to know that it doesn't go 100% smoothly for everyone else! I was talking about it with Mum this morning and we're starting to wonder whether there's another issue confusing things, because she goes in the right spot perfectly sometimes and then at other times chooses not to use the newspaper and go elsewhere - so, we're thinking, is there some REASON that sometimes she won't use the newspaper? I have a perfectly house-trained middle-aged terrier as well who holds on perfectly fine during the day - but I'm wondering if he has started using the paper as well for some reason and so if he's been there, she won't use it? Anyway, she's growing so quickly that she's going to be spending days outside from now on, but I'd really like to master this!! "Be consistent and persistant" is my motto with TT, so we'll keep at it. I'm sure I'm doing it right, I was just getting a bit worried about the time it's taking.