I've been feeding my greyhound and golden lab Meals For Mutts and have no complaints. I've tried the sardine and the duck ones. My only comment would be the duck version is quite high in fat which is good for my greyhound but stacks weight on the lab like crazy. The greyhound usually gets bored with her food after about a week of eating it, but that hasn't happened with this stuff so it's obviously quite palatable. In a ranking of foods I'd say it's definitely better than Black Hawk and probably on par with TOTW. As my dog gets bored easily, I need to change up her kibbles a lot so I'm always impressed when she consistently eats something for awhile. I usually add yoghurt, sardines or coconut oil to her food, so if you do this too, just watch the fat content. Greyhound metabolisms are so fast she can cope, but with other breeds, I'd probably be more watchful about additives.