laurenic33

PS her reason for using it is because she likes Australian owned brands.

I was looking at http://www.dogfoodanalysis.com/ and for example Eukanuba is listed as a 1 star product with plenty of reasoning behind it, Advance isn't listed because its Aussie owned but if Eukanuba is rated so poorly wouldn't Advance be similar? Whereas TOTW is considered 5 star & Holistic Select 4 star - both are very good. Also as per my initial post please read - I said ONLY Pacific Stream & Sierra Mountain from TOTW have appropriate protein, calc & phos levels. I'm aware of the required balance. The other flavours contain way too high protein. Holistic Select is also perfect ratio wise. I really thought id be able to get some opinions on these 2 brands which is honestly all I'm asking for.

Thanks all. The breeder is fully registered and reputable, but she is feeding the pups advance. I would prefer a higher quality brand. I know the change must be gradual. I just wanted to pls know which is preferred between TOTW and Holistic Select :)

I have decided between two brands of dry food for my new 8 week old Great Dane pup coming home next weekend. Taste of The Wild (ONLY either Sierra Mountain or Pacific Stream as these have acceptable protein/cal/phos levels) OR Holistic Select large breed puppy which again ticks the protein/cal/phos level boxes I've researched for days and read sooooo many reviews but all of it seems conflicting. So my questions are: Have you tried or are you currently using either of these dog foods? If so, what do you think? Which is better than the other and why? Please help! Thanks :)