We're not wanting to use a crate in the bedroom, but he is confined to the kitchen downstairs which is all tiled. Even if we're gone for an hour, and we take him out to wee and poo before we leave, we still come back to atleast one pee on the floor. It doesn't seem to be a matter of wether he can hold it or not, it's just that he goes where ever he can, and won't give us any indication before he does it (no noise, going to the door, sniffing around, etc.)