Occasionally I see pictures of Cesar Milan purposefully walking in front of his "pack" of dogs. He emphasises that in order to be acknowledged by the dogs as the boss (alpha, leader) you have to be in front, even when simply walking through a doorway. However, I'm not so sure about this. Here is why:
1. (On a personal note) my Vizsla instinctively walks in front of me, but turns glances at me regularly to see where I am going, and if I have altered my course, she alters hers accordingly. If I stop, she pauses, and if I'm standing for a couple of moments will run towards me and stand/sit next to me. To my mind, this indicates that I am leading her. If on a short leash, she'll trot along beside me.
2. If the instintive purpose of a Hunting Dog is flushing out game, it would be pretty rediculous to have it walk behind the human.
3. In a dog sled, the dogs are out in front. The top dog may be out the front and leading, but it still is under the command of the human in the sled. Do the front runner dogs think they rank higher than the human simply due to their proximity out in front?
4. When you see Military or Police Dogs with handlers, the dogs are out front for a variety of pretty obvious reasons. Who would suggest that the dog is in charge in these scenarios? I don't know if I am anthromorphizing , but it seems logical to have less ranking individuals out front, like in an army patrol. The dogs superior senses can locate dangers and this protects the leader.
5. On the issue of "don't let a dog go through a door before you"... isn't the dog just anticipating the human's movements, especially if its a routine? Seems to me the dog is acting like as escort rather than a boss.
I'd like to hear other peoples' opinions on this issue. Thank you!