Hi, Charles Kuntz here. I am a specialist surgeon in Melbourne and I thought I would put my two cents in. Medial patellar luxation is a problem that usually occurs in pure breed small dogs, although large pure breed dogs are affected as well. Mostly, they are congenital, but may be exacerbated by trauma. Medial patellar luxation is best described by the grade of the luxation. THey are graded 1,2,3 and 4. 1 is just loose. 2 is normally in but can be popped out, 3 is normally out but can be popped back in and 4 is always out. There was a study that showed that in dogs with bilateral (both sides) luxations, with only one side repaired, the function was significantly improved in the affected limb with surgery. There was no difference in radiographic signs of arthritis down the road.
The decision is based on the grade of luxation and on the age of the dog (and to some degree, the extent of lameness). Young dogs with grade 2 or above should generally have surgery. Older dogs that have a luxation with no debilitation can probably manage with conservative management. If the surgery is done properly, the success rate is very very high. I strongly recommend that the surgery include repositioning of the tibial crest because that is the primary problem (poor alignment of the tibial crest which drags the patella out of the groove). Revision of the trochlea (groove) is not usually recommended by me because of the extent of damage that it does to the joint cartilage). SOft tissue procedures alone ("tightening" the joint) are destined to fail.
There are great specialists around in Perth. The ones I know are at the vet school. Hope this helps.
Charles